James F. Bleeke

James F. Bleeke

Indianapolis, Indiana

James F. Bleeke has tried medical malpractice cases in federal and state courts throughout Indiana and state court in Florida. He has also tried a variety of other cases involving death, brain damage, and neurological injuries. The focus of Jim's practice is medical malpractice defense, nursing home defense, prisoner litigation, corrections cases, insurance defense and general litigation. Jim's appellate experience includes three arguments before the Seventh Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals. Indiana Super Lawyers selected Jim to appear in this distinguished list for 2010, which only chooses five percent of the lawyers in the state.

Prior to becoming a partner at BleekeDillonCrandall, Jim worked seven years at Ice Miller Donadio & Ryan in a broad-based litigation practice. In 1992, Jim became Litigation Manager and later Vice-President of Claims and Legal Affairs for Physicians Insurance Company of Indiana (now Pro Assurance) and served in that capacity until 1998. He continued defending medical malpractice cases on behalf of the insured physicians of Pro Assurance as an attorney for Arnold and Associates from 1998 through 2001.

Jim learned much during seven years at Ice Miller Donadio & Ryan, where his practice focused upon insurance defense, coal-related issues of black lung and mining regulation, UCC warranty law, and general litigation. He developed a particular affinity for working with and interrogating experts in medicine and other scientific fields, including mold cases. He also learned from one of the firm's founding partners, Jim Donadio, that an attorney's reputation for honesty, hard work and responsiveness to a client is invaluable. Jim Bleeke also has handled cases involving issues such as improper sterilization and re-use of single-use medical devices; tracheotomy errors; and airway and brain injuries.

Jim has spoken at seminars for the Indiana Continuing Legal Education Forum, the Indiana Podiatric Association, the National Business Institute and the Indiana Medical Directors Association as well as numerous risk management presentations for physicians and medical students.

Jim earned his undergraduate degree from Indiana University with highest distinction. He continued his studies in Bloomington and graduated cum laude from IU School of Law in 1985. Jim was a Note Editor for the Indiana Law Journal and interned for the Honorable United States District Judge Sarah Evans Barker while in law school.

Jim attempts to use the wisdom of the Bible whenever appropriate in his litigation practice. He believes that the concept of "loving your enemies" actually works quite well even in the context of litigation, when coupled with diligent preparation and a firm desire to confront the opposition with the weaknesses in their cases. Of course, Jim also understands it is imperative that the attorney carefully analyze the weaknesses in his own case and provide realistic advice to the client.

Areas of Practice

  • Medical Malpractice Defense
  • Nursing Home Defense
  • Prisoner Litigation
  • Corrections Cases
  • Insurance Defense
  • General Litigation

Litigation Percentage

  • 90% of Practice Devoted to Litigation

Bar Admissions

  • Indiana, 1985
  • U.S. Court of Appeals 7th Circuit


  • Indiana University at Bloomington School of Law, Bloomington, Indiana - 1985
    • Honors: cum laude
    • Law Journal: Indiana Law Journal, Note Editor
  • Indiana University
    • Honors: With High Distinction


  • Speaker, Indiana Continuing Legal Education Forum
  • Speaker, Indiana Podiatric Association
  • Speaker, National Business Institute
  • Speaker, Indiana Medical Directors Association

Honors and Awards

  • Indiana Super Lawyers, 2010

Past Employment Positions

  • Ice Miller Donadio & Ryan
  • Arnold and Associates, 1998 - 2001
  • Honorable United States District Judge Sarah Evans Barker , Intern

Pro Bono Activities

  • Litigation Manager, Claims and Legal Affairs for Physicians Insurance Company of Indiana
  • Vice-President, Claims and Legal Affairs for Physicians Insurance Company of Indiana
Peer Review Rated Super Lawyers
View More Videos